
Bard College-Commissioned Review Questions Authenticity of Botstein-Epstein Emails
By David SalazarA forensic review commissioned by Bard College found a “strong substantive basis” for questioning two emails in the Justice Department’s Epstein files. The emails purportedly show former Bard president Leon Botstein corresponding with Jeffrey Epstein about an individual identified as Jane Doe.
FTI Consulting delivered its report to Bard’s Board of Trustees on Oct. 19, 2026, responding to an Oct. 7 letter that cited the exchange as evidence Botstein assisted Epstein.
FTI found no trace of the emails in Bard’s Google Vault records, in preserved May 2014 correspondence, or in logs from the college’s July 2017 migration from Zimbra to Google Workspace. Searches of participants’ addresses and distinctive phrases turned up nothing.
The firm also flagged irregularities. The quoted message attributed to Epstein carries an abbreviated header reading “Sent: thurs 6 AM.” Six authenticated Epstein-Botstein emails from 2013 and 2014 instead show full weekdays, dates and timestamps to the second. Taken at face value, Botstein’s reply, stamped 12:45 a.m. on May 15, 2014, would predate the message it answers by five hours and 15 minutes, though differing time zones could explain this. Botstein’s message also appears only as quoted text inside an email Epstein forwarded to himself, with no native source email or transmission data.
Ultimately, FTI could not prove fabrication. The PDFs show no visible tampering, though alterations could have been made before they were created. Gaps in Vault indexing, migration records and original DOJ files constrained its conclusions. FTI did not assess whether the emails, if genuine, would support any allegation.
Per a statement issued by the College, “‘FTI established that the email in question has not existed on Bard’s server as far back as July 2017, more than a year before the Epstein scandal exploded into public view. As FTI wrote in its report, ‘[w]hile it is not possible at this time to establish with certainty that the exchange was entirely fabricated, indicators are clear that it is highly suspicious.’ Bard is a community that believes in transparency and the right to due process. Our review of the other claims in Representative Raskin’s letter remains ongoing, and we are committed to establishing the facts. In the meantime, we will continue our work to provide a secure and respectful learning environment for everyone at Bard.”
Categories
News

